OK, life has been moving along post-Jones.
Things were good in the Third Circuit.
"The police acted in the face of unsettled law at a time when courts were becoming more attuned to the argument that warrantless GPS surveillance violated the Fourth Amendment. Excluding the evidence here will incentivize the police to err on the side of constitutional behavior and help prevent future Fourth Amendment violations. We therefore conclude that the police actions taken here do not qualify under the good faith exception and hold that the exclusionary rule should apply in this case."
United States v. Katzin, 732 F.3d 187, 214 (3d Cir. 2013).
So no good-faith exception to the warrant requirement. . . .
BUT
On December 12, 2013, the Third Circuit granted rehearing en banc. Set for May 28, 2014. I guess we'll just stay tuned.
Red Dog
Federal criminal defense, blitzes and otherwise, in the Sixth Circuit and beyond.
To subscribe to this blog by e-mail, enter your e-mail address in the box below.
To subscribe to this blog by e-mail, enter your e-mail address in the box below.
Showing posts with label GPS. Show all posts
Showing posts with label GPS. Show all posts
Thursday, February 13, 2014
GPS Tracking, Warrants, and Good Faith
Labels:
Fourth Amendment,
GPS,
Search and Seizure,
Technology
Monday, March 5, 2012
More Tech News: Searching Cell Phones
United States v. Flores-Lopez, No. 10-3803 (7th Cir. Feb. 29, 2012) (for publication).
Judges Bauer, Posner, and Rovner.
Seventh Circuit affirms district court's finding that cell-phone call history was admissible despite the fact that this history was obtained b/c the police searched the phone, without a warrant, to obtain the phone's number.
This opinion is worth a read, especially on the heels of Jones and the GPS issue (see Jan. 25 post).
A quick summary:
* Opening a diary found on a suspect whom the police have arrested, to verify the suspect's name and address and to discover whether the diary contains information relevant to the crime for which the suspect has been arrested, is permissible. The cell-phone search is similar and "even less intrusive, since a cell phone’s phone number can be found without searching the phone’s contents."
* This search did not touch on the use of an iCam to view the home of the owner of the seized cell phone.
* Other conspirators were involved in the drug distribution and they conceivably could have learned of the arrests (they could have been monitoring the drug deal from afar) and they could have wiped the cell phone remotely before the government could obtain and execute a warrant and conduct a search pursuant to the warrant to find the cell phone’s number.
* It is conceivable that the defendant might have had time to warn co-conspirators before the cell phone was taken from him, allowing time to wipe the phone. While "conceivably” does not mean “probably,” the set off against the modest benefit to police of being able to obtain the cell phone’s phone number immediately comes at "only a modest cost in invasion of privacy."
* Armed with the phone number, the officers could obtain the call history at their leisure. And if the number was lawfully obtained, subpoenaing the call history from the phone company would also be lawful. A history thus obtained could properly be used in evidence against a defendant.
* It is "imperative" that officers have the authority to search or retrieve immediately, incident to a valid arrest, information from pagers in order to prevent destruction of evidence. Same holds here.
* The court could "certainly imagine justifications for a more extensive search." But the court leaves these questions for another day, as police here only obtained the phone’s number.
Labels:
Fourth Amendment,
GPS,
Search and Seizure,
Subpoenas,
Technology
Wednesday, January 25, 2012
Huge GPS Win! Must Have Warrant to Track with GPS!
United States v. Jones, No. 10-1259 (Jan. 23, 2012). Justice Scalia wrote the opinion. Chief Justice Roberts joined him, as did Justices Kennedy, Thomas, and Sotomayor. Justice Sotomayor also filed a concurring opinion. Justice Alito filed a separate opinion concurring in the judgment, and was joined by Justices Ginsburg, Breyer, and Kagan.
The Supreme Court has concluded that tracking a vehicle by attaching a GPS device to it is a search.
I know we've been seeing more and more of these cases in the district, especially in the Northern Division.
Authorities actually got a warrant to track the vehicle, but they installed the device after expiration of the warrant and outside of the authorized jurisdiction. Over the course of four weeks, the tracker relayed more than 2,000 pages of data.
Ultimately, gov charged defendant with cocaine offenses. Defense filed motion to suppress based on use of the GPS. Dist ct suppressed data obtained while the car was parked in the defendant's garage. Ct admitted rest of data b/c from public thoroughfares. A jury convicted the defendant and he received a sentence of life imprisonment.
The Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit reversed, finding that warrantless use of the GPS violated the Fourth Amendment.
Supreme Court held "that the Government's installation of a GPS devise on a target's vehicle, and its use of that devise to monitor the vehicle's movements, constitutes a 'search.'" The government here "physically occupied private property for the purpose of obtaining information."
The Court goes back to eighteenth- and nineteenth-century cases to discuss the original understanding of the Fourth Amendment. Fourth Amendment jurisprudence was tied to common-law trespass, at least until the later part of the last century. More recent cases have deviated from the exclusively property-based approach. Court cited Katz v. United States, 389 U.S. 347 (1967).
The Court concluded that "Fourth Amendment rights do not rise or fall with the Katz formulation" (the reasonable-expectation-of-privacy formulation). Rather, the Court must assure preservation of the degree of privacy that existed when the Fourth Amendment was adopted. For most of the country's history, the Fourth Amendment was understood to be concerned with government trespass upon the enumerated areas: persons, houses, papers, effects.
The Court discussed the "beeper cases," the cases that had posed problems in the GPS context b/c they had rejected Fourth Amendment challenges to using a beeper to track items: Knotts and Karo. The Court distinguished Knotts and Karo b/c the beeper was placed in the container with the consent of the owner at the time and prior to the container coming into the defendant's possession. Here, the defendant possessed the vehicle at the time the authorities installed the GPS.
Justice Sotomayor concurred:
* Found a search occurred.
* The reasonable-expectation-of-privacy test "augmented, but did not displace or diminish, the common-law trespassory test."
* Found that "the trespassory test applied in the majority's opinion reflects an irreducible constitutional minimum: When the Government physically invades personal property to gather information, a search occurs. The reaffirmation of that principle suffices to decide this case."
* Considered the issue of tracking that does not require trespass (e.g., factory-installed GPS devices tracked by the government).
* Cited Chief Judge Kozinski's (Ninth Cir.) opinion in Pineda-Moreno and acknowledged that "Awareness that the Government may be watching chills associational and expressive freedoms." The justice would take these factors into account when considering the existence of a reasonable societal expectation of privacy in one's movements.
Justice Alito also filed a separate concurrence:
* Believes the majority opinion "strains the language of the Fourth Amendment," is not supported by case law, and "is highly artificial."
* Would use the reasonable-expectation-of-privacy test.
* Finds that the majority disregards the potential impact of the GPS and potential use of the information, and attaches too much importance to the placement of the unit on the car. Explores some of the issues with property rights.
* Concedes there are problems with the reasonable-expectation-of-privacy test.
* Finds that short-term monitoring on public streets might be OK, but long-term monitoring would not be.
* Legislation, rather than case law, may be the best means for addressing the issues.
The Supreme Court has concluded that tracking a vehicle by attaching a GPS device to it is a search.
I know we've been seeing more and more of these cases in the district, especially in the Northern Division.
Authorities actually got a warrant to track the vehicle, but they installed the device after expiration of the warrant and outside of the authorized jurisdiction. Over the course of four weeks, the tracker relayed more than 2,000 pages of data.
Ultimately, gov charged defendant with cocaine offenses. Defense filed motion to suppress based on use of the GPS. Dist ct suppressed data obtained while the car was parked in the defendant's garage. Ct admitted rest of data b/c from public thoroughfares. A jury convicted the defendant and he received a sentence of life imprisonment.
The Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit reversed, finding that warrantless use of the GPS violated the Fourth Amendment.
Supreme Court held "that the Government's installation of a GPS devise on a target's vehicle, and its use of that devise to monitor the vehicle's movements, constitutes a 'search.'" The government here "physically occupied private property for the purpose of obtaining information."
The Court goes back to eighteenth- and nineteenth-century cases to discuss the original understanding of the Fourth Amendment. Fourth Amendment jurisprudence was tied to common-law trespass, at least until the later part of the last century. More recent cases have deviated from the exclusively property-based approach. Court cited Katz v. United States, 389 U.S. 347 (1967).
The Court concluded that "Fourth Amendment rights do not rise or fall with the Katz formulation" (the reasonable-expectation-of-privacy formulation). Rather, the Court must assure preservation of the degree of privacy that existed when the Fourth Amendment was adopted. For most of the country's history, the Fourth Amendment was understood to be concerned with government trespass upon the enumerated areas: persons, houses, papers, effects.
The Court discussed the "beeper cases," the cases that had posed problems in the GPS context b/c they had rejected Fourth Amendment challenges to using a beeper to track items: Knotts and Karo. The Court distinguished Knotts and Karo b/c the beeper was placed in the container with the consent of the owner at the time and prior to the container coming into the defendant's possession. Here, the defendant possessed the vehicle at the time the authorities installed the GPS.
Justice Sotomayor concurred:
* Found a search occurred.
* The reasonable-expectation-of-privacy test "augmented, but did not displace or diminish, the common-law trespassory test."
* Found that "the trespassory test applied in the majority's opinion reflects an irreducible constitutional minimum: When the Government physically invades personal property to gather information, a search occurs. The reaffirmation of that principle suffices to decide this case."
* Considered the issue of tracking that does not require trespass (e.g., factory-installed GPS devices tracked by the government).
* Cited Chief Judge Kozinski's (Ninth Cir.) opinion in Pineda-Moreno and acknowledged that "Awareness that the Government may be watching chills associational and expressive freedoms." The justice would take these factors into account when considering the existence of a reasonable societal expectation of privacy in one's movements.
Justice Alito also filed a separate concurrence:
* Believes the majority opinion "strains the language of the Fourth Amendment," is not supported by case law, and "is highly artificial."
* Would use the reasonable-expectation-of-privacy test.
* Finds that the majority disregards the potential impact of the GPS and potential use of the information, and attaches too much importance to the placement of the unit on the car. Explores some of the issues with property rights.
* Concedes there are problems with the reasonable-expectation-of-privacy test.
* Finds that short-term monitoring on public streets might be OK, but long-term monitoring would not be.
* Legislation, rather than case law, may be the best means for addressing the issues.
Labels:
Fourth Amendment,
GPS,
SCOTUS,
Search and Seizure
Thursday, October 27, 2011
GPS Before the S Ct in Nov!
OK, here's an exciting issue slated for oral argument in the S Ct on Nov 8.
United States v. Jones, No. 10-1259.
Questions Presented:
Does the warrantless use of a tracking device on a vehicle to monitor the vehicle's movements on public streets violate the Fourth Amendment?
Does the government violate a person's Fourth Amendment rights by installing a GPS tracking device on that person's vehicle without a valid warrant and without the person's consent?
We have seen more and more GPS cases in the district, so this issue is one to bear in mind! Preserve it!
United States v. Jones, No. 10-1259.
Questions Presented:
Does the warrantless use of a tracking device on a vehicle to monitor the vehicle's movements on public streets violate the Fourth Amendment?
Does the government violate a person's Fourth Amendment rights by installing a GPS tracking device on that person's vehicle without a valid warrant and without the person's consent?
We have seen more and more GPS cases in the district, so this issue is one to bear in mind! Preserve it!
Labels:
Fourth Amendment,
GPS,
SCOTUS,
Search and Seizure
Thursday, July 14, 2011
GPS in SCOTUS
On June 27, 2011, the Supreme Court granted cert in United States v. Antoine Jones, No. 10--1259 (June 27, 2011). Decision below at 615 F.3d 544.
Question Presented:
Whether warrantless use of tracking device on defendant's vehicle to monitor the vehicle's movements on public street violated the Fourth Amendment.
Court also directed the parties to brief and argue the issue of whether the government violated the defendant's Fourth Amendment rights by installing a GPS tracking device on the defendant's vehicle without a valid warrant and without the defendant's consent.
Question Presented:
Whether warrantless use of tracking device on defendant's vehicle to monitor the vehicle's movements on public street violated the Fourth Amendment.
Court also directed the parties to brief and argue the issue of whether the government violated the defendant's Fourth Amendment rights by installing a GPS tracking device on the defendant's vehicle without a valid warrant and without the defendant's consent.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

