United States v. Stewart, No. 12--1427 (6th Cir. Sept. 3, 2013) (for publication).
Panel of Judges Gilman, Griffin, and White.
D convicted of violating 18 U.S.C. 2252A(a)(1).
Facts:
* D flew into Detroit from Japan. Randomly approached by customs officer at int'l bag claim. Sent to secondary inspection area.
* Customs officer attempted to search one laptop, but couldn't b/c battery dead and power cord required int'l converter. While searching a second laptop, the officer found thumbnails of nude children. Officer held laptops for further examination, but released the D. ICE agent took computers to ICE office in Detroit.
* Forensic analyst previewed one laptop and found suspected CP. Officers got warrant. Did forensic exam. Found CP.
* In '09, grand jury charged D with transporting CP.
* D moved ct to dismiss case after passage of time based on speedy-trial grounds. (An error in the CM/ECF calendaring program put the trial date beyond the seventy-day period.) Ct dismissed case w/o prejudice.
* Grand jury brought a second indictment a month later.
Issues and Conclusions:
* Looking to U.S. v. Tinklenberg, 131 S. Ct. 2007 (2011), the COA concluded "the speedy-trial clock automatically stops when a defendant files any type of pretrial motion, including a motion to dismiss for a Speedy Trial Act violation." B/c one day remained on the speedy-trial clock when the D filed the original speedy-trial motion, that motion tolled the clock and there was no violation.
* The speedy-trial issue was reviewable here even though it was from the earlier case (otherwise, there could be no review). Footnote 1 addresses.
* D was not entitled to dismissal with prejudice. So subsequent indictment proper.
* The search of the computers in Detroit was not an "extended border search." The computers never cleared the border. This search was just a routine border search. No 4th Am violation.
* Cropping and brightening of pics could make the pics CP, even if original pics were not necessarily CP.
Red Dog
Federal criminal defense, blitzes and otherwise, in the Sixth Circuit and beyond.
To subscribe to this blog by e-mail, enter your e-mail address in the box below.
To subscribe to this blog by e-mail, enter your e-mail address in the box below.
Showing posts with label Speedy Trial. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Speedy Trial. Show all posts
Tuesday, September 3, 2013
Monday, April 15, 2013
Speedy-Trial Case Worth a Look
Another one from last week about which I just blogged on 6th Cir. blog.
US v. Heshelman, Nos. 10-1049/1223 (6th Cir. April 12, 2013) (not for publication).
Panel of Judges Clay, Gibbons, and White.
Dist ct said that an approximately three-year delay b/t indictment and trial not a speedy-trial violation. COA reversed.
Money laundering and fraud.
Indictment filed in 2006 (shortly before S of L expired) and was sealed, so gov could continue investigating. But gov didn't do much---just kept a journal of the defendant's contacts with the alleged victims.
Defendant one in Switzerland. Issue with potential extradition. Defendant got in touch with FBI agent b/c knew of investigation, which was hampering his business. Agent did not inform defendant of indictment, which had been filed at that point. Gov finally requested extradition from Switzerland in 2009. Trial commenced about four months later. Jury convicted on all counts.
A second defendant was told by FBI of warrant for his arrest in '08; defendant said he wanted to cooperate. Pleaded guilty about six months later.
First defendant complained of speedy-trial violation b/c of three-year delay in arrest and trial. Second defendant complained b/c gov knew of his whereabouts, but decided not to proceed with his trial until first defendant arrested.
Factors:
* Length of delay and defendant's assertion of rights. Trial delay of a year or more generally presumed prejudicial and triggers consideration of other factors. Gov conceded this presumption and that appellant asserted speedy-trial rights in timely manner.
* Reason for delay. Gov conceded it followed a "wait-and-see" course and sought to arrest the first defendant when the latter returned to the US to see family. Extradition difficult and gov wanted complete control of prosecution. But gov obligated to act diligently, even when a defendant is in a foreign country. Here, actively seeking extradition would not have been futile: there was an extradition treaty with Switzerland. Gov just didn't pursue extradition b/c didn't want Switzerland to place conditions on the extradition. But gov made only one attempt to see what conditions might be. Switzerland had been responsive. But gov just waited for the defendant's return to the US. Can't wait indefinitely. Defendant didn't flee the jurisdiction to avoid the charges; he had lived in Switzerland before the alleged scheme began.
* Prejudice. Presumption here, and gov didn't rebut.
First defendant's speedy-trial rights were violated.
As to second defendant:
* Gov could have arrested him at any time. Gov conceded presumptive prejudice. Also conceded timely assertion of rights.
* Once indictment unsealed and warrant for arrest issued, defendant two turned himself in.
* Gov also admitted that it delayed b/c if defendant two were tried alone he might prevail by just blaming defendant one. Gov interest in trying alleged co-conspirators together does not automatically justify delay. And gov did not delay while diligently searching for defendant one, as already discussed. Gov was just delaying extradition of defendant one.
Second defendant's speedy-trial rights violated.
Reversed and remanded with instructions to dismiss indictment with prejudice.
Concurrence by Judge Clay:
Agrees that speedy-trial rights violated. Looks more closely at reason for delay. What is standard of review? Considerable deference, according to SCOTUS. . . . Like clear-error review.
US v. Heshelman, Nos. 10-1049/1223 (6th Cir. April 12, 2013) (not for publication).
Panel of Judges Clay, Gibbons, and White.
Dist ct said that an approximately three-year delay b/t indictment and trial not a speedy-trial violation. COA reversed.
Money laundering and fraud.
Indictment filed in 2006 (shortly before S of L expired) and was sealed, so gov could continue investigating. But gov didn't do much---just kept a journal of the defendant's contacts with the alleged victims.
Defendant one in Switzerland. Issue with potential extradition. Defendant got in touch with FBI agent b/c knew of investigation, which was hampering his business. Agent did not inform defendant of indictment, which had been filed at that point. Gov finally requested extradition from Switzerland in 2009. Trial commenced about four months later. Jury convicted on all counts.
A second defendant was told by FBI of warrant for his arrest in '08; defendant said he wanted to cooperate. Pleaded guilty about six months later.
First defendant complained of speedy-trial violation b/c of three-year delay in arrest and trial. Second defendant complained b/c gov knew of his whereabouts, but decided not to proceed with his trial until first defendant arrested.
Factors:
* Length of delay and defendant's assertion of rights. Trial delay of a year or more generally presumed prejudicial and triggers consideration of other factors. Gov conceded this presumption and that appellant asserted speedy-trial rights in timely manner.
* Reason for delay. Gov conceded it followed a "wait-and-see" course and sought to arrest the first defendant when the latter returned to the US to see family. Extradition difficult and gov wanted complete control of prosecution. But gov obligated to act diligently, even when a defendant is in a foreign country. Here, actively seeking extradition would not have been futile: there was an extradition treaty with Switzerland. Gov just didn't pursue extradition b/c didn't want Switzerland to place conditions on the extradition. But gov made only one attempt to see what conditions might be. Switzerland had been responsive. But gov just waited for the defendant's return to the US. Can't wait indefinitely. Defendant didn't flee the jurisdiction to avoid the charges; he had lived in Switzerland before the alleged scheme began.
* Prejudice. Presumption here, and gov didn't rebut.
First defendant's speedy-trial rights were violated.
As to second defendant:
* Gov could have arrested him at any time. Gov conceded presumptive prejudice. Also conceded timely assertion of rights.
* Once indictment unsealed and warrant for arrest issued, defendant two turned himself in.
* Gov also admitted that it delayed b/c if defendant two were tried alone he might prevail by just blaming defendant one. Gov interest in trying alleged co-conspirators together does not automatically justify delay. And gov did not delay while diligently searching for defendant one, as already discussed. Gov was just delaying extradition of defendant one.
Second defendant's speedy-trial rights violated.
Reversed and remanded with instructions to dismiss indictment with prejudice.
Concurrence by Judge Clay:
Agrees that speedy-trial rights violated. Looks more closely at reason for delay. What is standard of review? Considerable deference, according to SCOTUS. . . . Like clear-error review.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)